Back to Index

## 
## ********************* PROCESS for R Version 4.1.1 ********************* 
##  
##            Written by Andrew F. Hayes, Ph.D.  www.afhayes.com              
##    Documentation available in Hayes (2022). www.guilford.com/p/hayes3   
##  
## *********************************************************************** 
##  
## PROCESS is now ready for use.
## Copyright 2022 by Andrew F. Hayes ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
## Workshop schedule at http://haskayne.ucalgary.ca/CCRAM
## 

Direct Effects

## 
## Call:
## lm(formula = blame_post ~ manip_check, data = df)
## 
## Residuals:
##     Min      1Q  Median      3Q     Max 
## -5.4269 -0.4269  0.5731  0.6810  0.7890 
## 
## Coefficients:
##             Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)    
## (Intercept)  5.21102    0.09973  52.254   <2e-16 ***
## manip_check  0.03598    0.02405   1.496    0.136    
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## Residual standard error: 1.043 on 298 degrees of freedom
## Multiple R-squared:  0.007458,   Adjusted R-squared:  0.004128 
## F-statistic: 2.239 on 1 and 298 DF,  p-value: 0.1356

character

Mediation analysis: manip_check -> character -> blame_post

## 
## ********************* PROCESS for R Version 4.1.1 ********************* 
##  
##            Written by Andrew F. Hayes, Ph.D.  www.afhayes.com              
##    Documentation available in Hayes (2022). www.guilford.com/p/hayes3   
##  
## *********************************************************************** 
##                    
## Model : 4          
##     Y : blame_post 
##     X : manip_check
##     M : character  
## 
## Sample size: 300
## 
## Custom seed: 1234
## 
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: character
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.1561     0.0244     1.5564     7.4436     1.0000   298.0000     0.0067
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        2.3963     0.1193    20.0799     0.0000     2.1614     2.6311
## manip_check    -0.0785     0.0288    -2.7283     0.0067    -0.1351    -0.0219
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: blame_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.2815     0.0792     1.0117    12.7766     2.0000   297.0000     0.0000
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        5.7495     0.1476    38.9562     0.0000     5.4590     6.0399
## manip_check     0.0183     0.0235     0.7810     0.4355    -0.0279     0.0646
## character      -0.2247     0.0467    -4.8112     0.0000    -0.3166    -0.1328
## 
## ************************ TOTAL EFFECT MODEL *************************** 
## Outcome Variable: blame_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.0864     0.0075     1.0869     2.2393     1.0000   298.0000     0.1356
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        5.2110     0.0997    52.2538     0.0000     5.0148     5.4073
## manip_check     0.0360     0.0240     1.4964     0.1356    -0.0113     0.0833
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Bootstrapping in progress. Please wait.
## 
## ************ TOTAL, DIRECT, AND INDIRECT EFFECTS OF X ON Y ************
## 
## Total effect of X on Y:
##       effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
##       0.0360     0.0240     1.4964     0.1356    -0.0113     0.0833
## 
## Direct effect of X on Y:
##       effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
##       0.0183     0.0235     0.7810     0.4355    -0.0279     0.0646
## 
## Indirect effect(s) of X on Y:
##               Effect     BootSE   BootLLCI   BootULCI
## character     0.0176     0.0082     0.0041     0.0360
## 
## Normal theory test for indirect effect(s):
##               Effect         se          Z          p
## character     0.0176     0.0076     2.3354     0.0195
## 
## ******************** ANALYSIS NOTES AND ERRORS ************************ 
## 
## Level of confidence for all confidence intervals in output: 95
## 
## Number of bootstraps for percentile bootstrap confidence intervals: 10000

wrongness

Mediation analysis: manip_check -> wrongness -> blame_post

## 
## ********************* PROCESS for R Version 4.1.1 ********************* 
##  
##            Written by Andrew F. Hayes, Ph.D.  www.afhayes.com              
##    Documentation available in Hayes (2022). www.guilford.com/p/hayes3   
##  
## *********************************************************************** 
##                    
## Model : 4          
##     Y : blame_post 
##     X : manip_check
##     M : wrongness  
## 
## Sample size: 300
## 
## Custom seed: 1234
## 
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: wrongness
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.1293     0.0167     0.5772     5.0655     1.0000   298.0000     0.0251
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        5.5529     0.0727    76.4126     0.0000     5.4099     5.6959
## manip_check     0.0394     0.0175     2.2507     0.0251     0.0050     0.0739
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: blame_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.4959     0.2459     0.8286    48.4213     2.0000   297.0000     0.0000
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        1.4761     0.3951     3.7358     0.0002     0.6985     2.2537
## manip_check     0.0095     0.0212     0.4467     0.6554    -0.0322     0.0511
## wrongness       0.6726     0.0694     9.6905     0.0000     0.5360     0.8092
## 
## ************************ TOTAL EFFECT MODEL *************************** 
## Outcome Variable: blame_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.0864     0.0075     1.0869     2.2393     1.0000   298.0000     0.1356
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        5.2110     0.0997    52.2538     0.0000     5.0148     5.4073
## manip_check     0.0360     0.0240     1.4964     0.1356    -0.0113     0.0833
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Bootstrapping in progress. Please wait.
## 
## ************ TOTAL, DIRECT, AND INDIRECT EFFECTS OF X ON Y ************
## 
## Total effect of X on Y:
##       effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
##       0.0360     0.0240     1.4964     0.1356    -0.0113     0.0833
## 
## Direct effect of X on Y:
##       effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
##       0.0095     0.0212     0.4467     0.6554    -0.0322     0.0511
## 
## Indirect effect(s) of X on Y:
##               Effect     BootSE   BootLLCI   BootULCI
## wrongness     0.0265     0.0115     0.0029     0.0483
## 
## Normal theory test for indirect effect(s):
##               Effect         se          Z          p
## wrongness     0.0265     0.0122     2.1813     0.0292
## 
## ******************** ANALYSIS NOTES AND ERRORS ************************ 
## 
## Level of confidence for all confidence intervals in output: 95
## 
## Number of bootstraps for percentile bootstrap confidence intervals: 10000

justification

Mediation analysis: manip_check -> justification -> blame_post

## 
## ********************* PROCESS for R Version 4.1.1 ********************* 
##  
##            Written by Andrew F. Hayes, Ph.D.  www.afhayes.com              
##    Documentation available in Hayes (2022). www.guilford.com/p/hayes3   
##  
## *********************************************************************** 
##                      
## Model : 4            
##     Y : blame_post   
##     X : manip_check  
##     M : justification
## 
## Sample size: 300
## 
## Custom seed: 1234
## 
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: justification
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.1073     0.0115     1.3824     3.4711     1.0000   298.0000     0.0634
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        0.7537     0.1125     6.7018     0.0000     0.5324     0.9751
## manip_check    -0.0505     0.0271    -1.8631     0.0634    -0.1039     0.0028
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: blame_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.5621     0.3160     0.7515    68.6073     2.0000   297.0000     0.0000
## 
## Model: 
##                    coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant          5.5837     0.0890    62.7693     0.0000     5.4086     5.7587
## manip_check       0.0110     0.0201     0.5472     0.5847    -0.0286     0.0506
## justification    -0.4944     0.0427   -11.5748     0.0000    -0.5784    -0.4103
## 
## ************************ TOTAL EFFECT MODEL *************************** 
## Outcome Variable: blame_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.0864     0.0075     1.0869     2.2393     1.0000   298.0000     0.1356
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        5.2110     0.0997    52.2538     0.0000     5.0148     5.4073
## manip_check     0.0360     0.0240     1.4964     0.1356    -0.0113     0.0833
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Bootstrapping in progress. Please wait.
## 
## ************ TOTAL, DIRECT, AND INDIRECT EFFECTS OF X ON Y ************
## 
## Total effect of X on Y:
##       effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
##       0.0360     0.0240     1.4964     0.1356    -0.0113     0.0833
## 
## Direct effect of X on Y:
##       effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
##       0.0110     0.0201     0.5472     0.5847    -0.0286     0.0506
## 
## Indirect effect(s) of X on Y:
##                   Effect     BootSE   BootLLCI   BootULCI
## justification     0.0250     0.0121     0.0013     0.0490
## 
## Normal theory test for indirect effect(s):
##                   Effect         se          Z          p
## justification     0.0250     0.0136     1.8328     0.0668
## 
## ******************** ANALYSIS NOTES AND ERRORS ************************ 
## 
## Level of confidence for all confidence intervals in output: 95
## 
## Number of bootstraps for percentile bootstrap confidence intervals: 10000

guilt

Mediation analysis: manip_check -> guilt -> blame_post

## 
## ********************* PROCESS for R Version 4.1.1 ********************* 
##  
##            Written by Andrew F. Hayes, Ph.D.  www.afhayes.com              
##    Documentation available in Hayes (2022). www.guilford.com/p/hayes3   
##  
## *********************************************************************** 
##                    
## Model : 4          
##     Y : blame_post 
##     X : manip_check
##     M : guilt      
## 
## Sample size: 300
## 
## Custom seed: 1234
## 
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: guilt
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.1323     0.0175     2.8423     5.3052     1.0000   298.0000     0.0220
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        4.3762     0.1613    27.1362     0.0000     4.0588     4.6935
## manip_check    -0.0896     0.0389    -2.3033     0.0220    -0.1661    -0.0130
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: blame_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.0871     0.0076     1.0904     1.1364     2.0000   297.0000     0.3224
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        5.1793     0.1861    27.8315     0.0000     4.8131     5.5455
## manip_check     0.0366     0.0243     1.5076     0.1327    -0.0112     0.0845
## guilt           0.0072     0.0359     0.2020     0.8401    -0.0634     0.0779
## 
## ************************ TOTAL EFFECT MODEL *************************** 
## Outcome Variable: blame_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.0864     0.0075     1.0869     2.2393     1.0000   298.0000     0.1356
## 
## Model: 
##                  coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant        5.2110     0.0997    52.2538     0.0000     5.0148     5.4073
## manip_check     0.0360     0.0240     1.4964     0.1356    -0.0113     0.0833
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Bootstrapping in progress. Please wait.
## 
## ************ TOTAL, DIRECT, AND INDIRECT EFFECTS OF X ON Y ************
## 
## Total effect of X on Y:
##       effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
##       0.0360     0.0240     1.4964     0.1356    -0.0113     0.0833
## 
## Direct effect of X on Y:
##       effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
##       0.0366     0.0243     1.5076     0.1327    -0.0112     0.0845
## 
## Indirect effect(s) of X on Y:
##           Effect     BootSE   BootLLCI   BootULCI
## guilt    -0.0006     0.0045    -0.0106     0.0083
## 
## Normal theory test for indirect effect(s):
##           Effect         se          Z          p
## guilt    -0.0006     0.0035    -0.1847     0.8535
## 
## ******************** ANALYSIS NOTES AND ERRORS ************************ 
## 
## Level of confidence for all confidence intervals in output: 95
## 
## Number of bootstraps for percentile bootstrap confidence intervals: 10000

SFC

Mediation analysis: condition -> SFC -> punish_post

## 
## ********************* PROCESS for R Version 4.1.1 ********************* 
##  
##            Written by Andrew F. Hayes, Ph.D.  www.afhayes.com              
##    Documentation available in Hayes (2022). www.guilford.com/p/hayes3   
##  
## *********************************************************************** 
##                    
## Model : 4          
##     Y : punish_post
##     X : condition_1
##     M : SFC        
## 
## Sample size: 300
## 
## Custom seed: 1234
## 
## Coding of categorical X variable for analysis: 
##   condition_1         X1         X2
##        0.0000     0.0000     0.0000
##        1.0000     1.0000     0.0000
##        2.0000     0.0000     1.0000
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: SFC
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.1406     0.0198     2.1959     2.9966     2.0000   297.0000     0.0515
## 
## Model: 
##               coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant     2.9899     0.1489    20.0755     0.0000     2.6968     3.2830
## X1           0.4701     0.2101     2.2376     0.0260     0.0566     0.8836
## X2           0.4160     0.2096     1.9851     0.0480     0.0036     0.8285
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Outcome Variable: punish_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.2921     0.0853     1.0656     9.2067     3.0000   296.0000     0.0000
## 
## Model: 
##               coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant     4.2413     0.1593    26.6287     0.0000     3.9279     4.5548
## X1           0.0577     0.1476     0.3912     0.6959    -0.2327     0.3482
## X2           0.1775     0.1470     1.2081     0.2280    -0.1117     0.4668
## SFC          0.1997     0.0404     4.9404     0.0000     0.1201     0.2792
## 
## ************************ TOTAL EFFECT MODEL *************************** 
## Outcome Variable: punish_post
## 
## Model Summary: 
##            R       R-sq        MSE          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.0996     0.0099     1.1495     1.4887     2.0000   297.0000     0.2273
## 
## Model: 
##               coeff         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## constant     4.8384     0.1078    44.9009     0.0000     4.6263     5.0504
## X1           0.1516     0.1520     0.9974     0.3194    -0.1475     0.4508
## X2           0.2606     0.1516     1.7188     0.0867    -0.0378     0.5590
## 
## *********************************************************************** 
## Bootstrapping in progress. Please wait.
## 
## ************ TOTAL, DIRECT, AND INDIRECT EFFECTS OF X ON Y ************
## 
## Relative total effects of X on Y:
##        effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## X1     0.1516     0.1520     0.9974     0.3194    -0.1475     0.4508
## X2     0.2606     0.1516     1.7188     0.0867    -0.0378     0.5590
## 
## Omnibus test of total effect of X on Y:
##      R2-chng          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.0099     1.4887     2.0000   297.0000     0.2273
## ----------
## 
## Relative direct effects of X on Y:
##        effect         se          t          p       LLCI       ULCI
## X1     0.0577     0.1476     0.3912     0.6959    -0.2327     0.3482
## X2     0.1775     0.1470     1.2081     0.2280    -0.1117     0.4668
## 
## Omnibus test of direct effect of X on Y:
##      R2-chng          F        df1        df2          p
##       0.0047     0.7644     2.0000   296.0000     0.4665
## 
## ----------
## 
## Relative indirect effects of X on Y:
## 
## condition_1    ->    SFC    ->    punish_post
## 
##        Effect     BootSE   BootLLCI   BootULCI
## X1     0.0939     0.0486     0.0095     0.2012
## X2     0.0831     0.0474    -0.0009     0.1854
## 
##    Normal theory test for relative indirect effects:
##        Effect         se          Z          p
## X1     0.0939     0.0468     2.0045     0.0450
## X2     0.0831     0.0459     1.8104     0.0702
## 
## ******************** ANALYSIS NOTES AND ERRORS ************************ 
## 
## Level of confidence for all confidence intervals in output: 95
## 
## Number of bootstraps for percentile bootstrap confidence intervals: 10000